data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/47c1b/47c1bf40e40aef72169bad08eaa54e8d29e082b9" alt="Quote"
Originally Posted by
Steve M
To the OP - based on what you wrote, this is what stood out to me:
I can't tell what your intended use is - you say you aren't driving it to church, and you aren't tracking it, so what exactly are you doing, and how is what you are currently using falling short of your expectations?
If you are looking for a tire that can do it all, that is:
1. Great street manners - quiet, doesn't tramline, etc.
2. Great tread life
3. Looks great (does that matter to you? It does to some...)
4. Doesn't cost a fortune
5. Great track performance
It doesn't exist. Everything is going to be a compromise. So what compromises are you willing to make?
More importantly, why can't you just keep using what you are using? If you've already found a combo that works for you, I'd say just keep on rolling with it until it either doesn't work anymore, or they stop making them.
You really need to define what you are intending to do, though, and you also need to identify what you dislike about what you've used so far. What didn't you like about the Invos? Sidewalls too soft? Too squirmy? Do you want excellent handling in the corners, or do you need straight line acceleration performance? Depending on power levels, you may never get a tire to hook in first gear on the street outside of a set of drag radials, and not everyone wants to run those all the time. Does straight line acceleration performance even matter to you?
I've only had 4 sets of tires over the ~10 years I've owned my car:
1. Michelin Pilot Sport PS2 C1 - OEM tires, but they had ~10,000 miles on them, and needed replaced immediately after buying them.
2. Michelin Pilot Super Sports - these were good all around street tires, but they would not hold up to heavy track use. They also didn't hook for shit at the drag strip.
3. Pirelli PZero - these did not inspire confidence like the Pilot SS. They weren't bad, but I just wasn't all that thrilled with them. For straight line acceleration performance, they couldn't hold first or second gear WOT pulls on the street at my current power levels (I'd guess I'm around 520 RWHP or so, but the 3.55s don't help).
4. Toyo R888R - the noise. My god the noise. I know people like Jon B look down their nose at guys like me that complain about tire noise, but it's a big problem if I can't tell if the racket is being caused by tires or a serious mechanical issue with my car. They are THAT loud. They also tramline like a mofo on anything but the smoothest, newest pavement.
I've also tried two different drag radials, but I'm not going into either of those since I don't think that's what you are after here.
I will not be going with the R888Rs again, so I consider my lesson learned. For my application (99% street, 1% drag strip), I need a good all around street tire that has at least somewhat reasonable straight line performance (I need it to at least hook on a 2nd gear WOT pull). Due to that, I will likely try the Continentals next (the street tires, not the competitor with the R888R). I'm also heavily considering going back to 3.07s out back with a revised 5th and 6th gear that will help reduce the burden on the tires, but that's a different discussion for a different day.
Bottom line: if you have something that works, just keep using it. Sometimes you have to waste money to figure out what you like and don't like, but I'm starting to grow tired of that method, and I'd never recommend it to someone else. Be honest about how you use your car and what you are willing to tolerate out of a tire - I found my limits with the R888R, but others love them. Can't please everyone I suppose.
Good luck...if you try something new, please provide feedback so the community can benefit.
Bookmarks